Advanced Strategies: How Much Should an Apartment Building Cost?
(back to top)
A student sent me a question about apartments...
Q. We still remember the excitement and fun of your seminar in Las
Vegas. We continue to pursue our real estate investment business
here in western Washington. We got a call from a broker the other
day about a property that seems like it would be good for us, but
wanted your opinion about the matter.
This is a six building, 70-unit apartment complex located in our
area. The broker whom we have been communicating with says that
this is not on the MLS yet. He has been asking around as requested
by one of the owners. We contacted him recently on another property
and that is why he called us. This complex is in a corporation
jointly owned by a retired doctor and his wife, the builder and his
wife, and the doctor's daughter and son-in-law. The doctor is in
his seventies and asked the broker to put out some feelers because
lately he has been thinking of the fact that he will not be doing
this as a business much longer. An offer was made recently for 2.8
million and was turned down by the one of the members because he
felt it was worth more. They want 3.2 million for these six
buildings housing 70 units.
They were built starting in 1986. Some deferred maintenance does
exist with regard to the six composition roof tops with an expected
life of 20 years each. They look to be in good shape now but will
have to start being replaced in about three years at about $8500 a
pop! Other than that, the buildings look to be very well kept and
the management boasts of 100% occupancy and no advertising budget!
There are 8 Sec 8 units and most of the residents in these 6
buildings are long term renters. The broker feels that the rents
are a bit low, thus 100% occupancy, and could be raised about $ 40
per month (up from $550 for the 58 2 bedrooms and $450 for the 12 1
bedrooms) with out many repercussions. Buildings 1 & 2 were built
in 1989. Building number 3 was built in 1990. Buildings 4, 5, &
6 were built in 1991. The broker refers to the depreciation and
interest expenses as "funny money" and that is how he came up with
the increased NOI (net operating income) of $238,514. He has
advised us to put in the offer our request for 3 years tax returns
or verifiable and auditable expense records. He doesn't see a
problem with us getting those, but is unwilling to ask for them
without our offer. He further feels that had they countered the
previous $2.8 million offer with a $3 Million counter offer that
it would have been accepted and we would not be talking about this
property now.
The numbers that we have so far are:
Rent roll $417,486.00
Other income $606.87
Expenses:
Accounting Fees $1,782.50
Amortization Expense $1,272.07
Bank Service Charges $26.00
Credit Reports $662.00
Depreciation Expense $76,414.00
Dues and Subscriptions $130.00
Insurance $8,692.00
Interest Expense $38,488.27
Legal Fees $547.80
Maintenance $24,002.35
NSF Fees $45.00
Office Supplies $458.29
Payroll Expenses $30,509.48
Building Repairs $1,845.04
Returned Securities Deposits $1,829.17
Taxes $38,954.04
Utilities (phone, cable, electric, fire monitoring,
garbage, sewer/water) $68,318.92
Total Expenses $259,702.79
NOI $122,390.08
How should we proceed on this? What should the offer look
like? Should we hand the broker three contracts, all different
in some respect like I have heard mentioned on occasion? Since
there are five people (one of the six died recently) involved in
the decision making process, I would like to give them choices.
Cheyanne has expressed some concern about the cap rate being too
low and the multiplier being too high but if the buildings can
take care of themselves, then this might be a good investment for
us. The broker would like us to get back to him right away. We
have not really thought of how we will fund this investment.
What suggestions do you have in that regard?
Thanks again for all of your help with our continued knowledge
gathering in this business. We look forward to our next contact
with you.
Sam and Cheyanne
A. My first reaction was this is a really long email!
However,
you told me what I needed to know and I ran some numbers for you.
Real expenses are $174,596, because Interest expense and
depreciation are not subtracted out before you find the NOI.
With an income of $418,092.87 this gives you an expense ratio of
about 41.7%, which is about right. So, the numbers look real.
If there is no deferred maintenance, expenses should be 40 to 45
per cent on most apartments. Adding NOI ($122,390.08) plus
Depreciation Expense ($76,414.00) plus $8,692.00 gives an adjusted
Net Operating Income or NOI of $207,496.
At a sales price of $3,000,000 you would have a yield of 6.9%,
which is low.
At $3,100,000 the yield is 6.59%. I would be much happier with
a yield of 8 per cent which would be $2,600,000. But then, I
like good deals and this is a reasonable deal only. To my mind,
if he had received an offer for $3,000,000, he should have taken
it. You would have to get a loan at around 6% to make this deal
look good and that is difficult if not impossible. Add to this
that some of the roofs need replacement, and it is even less
attractive. Share these numbers with the broker and see what he
says. Sad news is, even though the rental market is soft, and
rents are down, there are quite a few investors chasing the few
projects that are on the market. So, apartments are hot and they
may find someone who will buy the complex at over $3,000,000!
Do you have $300,000 to $450,000 it will take as a down payment?
How is your credit score? If this does not work out, remember,
there are more buyers for $700,000 deals than for $3,000,000
deals and the buyers and sellers of $3,000,000 deals can eat you
for lunch. Also remember that $15,000 profit a deal on ten house
deals will get you there just as well as an apartment deal.
BZ